30642
Fans

How to Be Immune to Unfair Criticism

Jun
09
2010

by Sibyl · 41 comments

Have you ever noticed those people that have an opinion on just about anything you say or do? Some people believe it is their responsibility to tell you if you have made a mistake or correct things about you they have decided need to change.

The world is filled with advisors.  Whether it is someone close to us, like a family member or a friend, or someone who is more removed, like a co-worker or a stranger on the street; it is common to run into people that feel entitled to give you advice and share their thoughts on how and what you could and should be doing better.

And, some of this advice can really be helpful.  Sometimes people share good and constructive criticism that helps us understand more about ourselves, our strengths, our opportunity areas, and how we are being perceived.  This is the advice and information we want to listen to and use to learn and grow.

However, sometimes the advice is not useful and is only unfair or biased criticism. Not only is it not helpful, but it can strike us at our core and break down our own confidence. We are taught from a young age that we should dismiss comments when people are simply being rude and trying to insult us. We should have thick skin and simply turn the other cheek.

But, many times it is much easier said than done to simply dismiss these comments. Despite the fact we have reminded ourselves over and over again to have thick skin, to blow off their comments and focus on moving forward, we may end up falling into the trap of getting angry and really disturbed. Although we may pretend we are not bothered or affected by their thoughts, in actuality our skin is not as thick as we think and we find ourselves continually reflecting on their criticism and how it made us feel. We have allowed their criticism to invade our peace of mind.

And, since it is inevitable we will encounter unfair criticism at some point, and perhaps at many points, we need a perspective that will get us to the peace of mind we really need as soon as possible. We need something that will really ensure we have thick skin and that unfair criticism rolls right off of us.  We need an alternaview.

The alternaview

When people say things that are hurtful and hit us at our core, the best thing we can do is take a step back, objectively look at the situation and decide we are going to be our own judge.  Instead of handing over control and reacting to what they said, getting upset, defensive or trying to convince them why they are mistaken, we should view the situation as an opportunity to look within and be our own judge. We get to complete our own objective self analysis and decide if they have identified anything we really need to work on or if we should just move on and continue what we have been doing because their advice and criticism is unfounded.

We should ask ourselves if what we have done or how we have behaved is consistent with our own truth and who we know we should be.  We should honestly explore their criticism, but if we conclude we have not abandoned any of our core beliefs and the truth we know, then we should dismiss their criticism and continue to follow what we know is right. We should not let anyone lead us astray and we should stay focused on our own truth.

Why?

Because when people have criticized us unfairly and upset us, the best way to restore our frame of mind is to know we are doing the right thing and following what we know to be true. As long as that is genuinely the case, we can keep reminding ourselves of that reality, and that will allow us to more easily dismiss what they have said.  That will allow us to move on and really develop thick skin because when we know we are doing the right thing there should be nothing that other people say that can change that reality.

How to use this alternaview:

1. Stay Calm: When people criticize you and say something that is totally unfair, focus on staying calm and not emotionally reacting to them.  Don’t allow the situation to escalate and suck you in deeper because that will make your honest evaluation of their criticism and the return to your peace of mind take longer.  It’s okay to dismiss yourself from the situation, go have some private time and express your emotion and frustration while you are alone … get it out and release it if that helps you. But, never engage your critic in debate or get defensive.  It will get you nowhere.

2. Find a way to Have Good Thoughts About the Person. Think 5 good things about the person who criticized you.  Yes, in many instances this can be very challenging at first.  The reality is though that many people have other personal issues going on and they haven’t figured out how to control themselves and not allow their issues to negatively impact others. Their actions and comments can’t be justified, but if you are able to see they have some “behind the scene” things going on, it makes it easier to see them in a better light.  And, when you can do this, it eliminates a lot of anger or frustration that you may have toward them.

3. Survey Yourself. Do all you can to see things from their perspective and ask yourself if there is anything you could have done better.  Whatever it is they are criticizing, ask yourself about it and if you behaved in a way that you are proud of. Was what you did or said consistent with your core beliefs and what you know is right?  Be open minded and honest while doing this exploration.  It is okay if you can see some truth in what they are saying.  It just means this is one of those times you get to learn and grow.

4. Your Truth Trumps. Realize that if you feel very good about what you did or said and after your survey, you feel you have lived up to your own truth and core beliefs, then your truth trumps.  If you have followed your own truth and have done what you know is right, then your truth trumps anything that anyone else has to say about you. Continually reflect on the fact that you have followed your own truth and done what you know is right.  There is nothing better than that.

Conclusion

It is inevitable that people are going to criticize you and say things about you that are unfair and untrue.  However, if you are following what you know to be right and have truth on your side, there is nothing they can say that should be of any consequence. When your own truth and doing the right thing is your tail wind, it is much easier to dismiss unfair criticism and move forward … that is the alternaview.

Are you immune to unfair criticism?  Do you agree with this alternaview?  Please share your thoughts in the comment section below.

Leave a comment

Leave a Comment

{ 40 comments… read them below or add one }

Wilma Ham June 9, 2010 at 10:43 pm

Hi Sibyl.
Yes criticism and attacks are always hard to deal with and attack is often the ego’s way so we are subjected to it too regularly and of course our ego retaliates back in return. I love how you point out how to go beyond the knee jerk reaction of our own ego. At least war is avoided and as you say you might get a win out of itby learning something. xox Wilma
.-= Wilma Ham´s last blog ..Do you pay attention? =-.

Reply

Sibyl June 10, 2010 at 4:58 am

Wilma: Thanks for the comment. As you mentioned, criticism and attacks are always hard to deal with, but if we learn how to manage them, we can avoid having them overtake us and cause us to react in ways we know are not helpful. I think it is all about working at this overtime and becoming better and better. Thank you so much for the comment. I really appreciate it.

Reply

Sandra Hendricks June 9, 2010 at 11:28 pm

Hi Sibyl,

I agree that it is important to put some thoughts toward what is said, to recognize if we need to work on something. I try to keep in mind that a lot of what other people say to us, is what they are thinking of themselves. It is often the case of deflecting thoughts that can cause people to be mean or abusive. When we decide that we are okay with our actions, we can understand. This understanding can help us practice empathy, and respond, instead of reacting.

Thanks for the Alternative View!

Warm Regards,
Sandra
.-= Sandra Hendricks´s last blog ..We Are All Unique – There is No Comparison =-.

Reply

Sibyl June 10, 2010 at 5:01 am

Sandra: Thank you so much for the comment. I agree with you that it is all about finding that place within yourself where you are comfortable with your actions and decisions. This really does allow you to handle other people’s criticism in the best manner because you are grounded in your own truth. I also liked what you said about understanding that can help us practice empathy and respond instead of reacting. Thanks for stopping by the alternaview. It is great to have you commenting here.

Reply

Baker June 10, 2010 at 2:07 am

Hello Sibyl
Another insightful and amazing post here!!! Yes. I would say for me in my life, taking a step back when faced with unfair critcism has helped me out a lot. Many times I have to take that step back and see where the other person is coming from. Sometimes it is their own issue they haven’t yet dealt with themselves. It is important to stay calm and step back many times to get a better feel or read on the situation.

Reply

Sibyl June 10, 2010 at 5:03 am

Baker: Thank you so much for the comment. I thought what you said about getting a better read on the situation was so important. It is easy to get caught up in what is going on and react to the situation instead of trying to understand it and choosing to act in a way we know will be the most helpful. It really is like you said … all about taking a step back. Thanks again for the comment.

Reply

Annie Stith (@Gr8fulAnnie) June 10, 2010 at 7:27 am

Hey, Sibyl!

Love your blog (not just this particular post, BTW)!

I think you hit it right on the nose — if we look inside to our core, and to the Mission Statement of the subject/project involved, we will know and feel it when we take “right action,” even before the harsh criticism. Working on setting up my own website/blog, I believe this is part of my process as I prepare to go public. (Eeeek!) For every component, I review whether it fits me and what it is I’m attempting to accomplish.

I’m both a writer and a huge fan of journaling, so I would add the suggestion of writing down the initial reaction to the critic’s harsh words. I’ve written many an anger letter, and enjoyed watching them go up in flames or ripping them to shreds. If the critic is someone especially close, such as family or a long-time friend, this works especially well to make sure none of my reaction slips out of my mouth when I’m around them.

I also appreciate the fact you included “when you are alone” to getting out the emotional reaction. This is not the time to talk to family, friends or associates who know both you and your critic. Trying to influence others’ opinions or win them over to “your side” when you’re emotional is something you might very well regret later.

Keep up the great posts!

Annie

Reply

Sibyl June 10, 2010 at 9:22 pm

Annie: Thanks for the comment and the kind words. I think that writing down your initial reaction instead of actually getting caught up in responding is a really good solution. It accomplishes what should be your main goal, which is calming things down and not emotionally responding. I also think that we will really know when we are moving in the right direction and having the right reactions. Please keep us updated about your blog and when it does go public. I am looking forward to reading it. I am sure it will be great. Thanks again for the comment.

Reply

Anita June 10, 2010 at 9:45 am

Great post again Sibyl. The easiest way out of confrontation is to get hurt or ofended. But as you point out, it’s a lot more useful to stop for a second. See if your actions align with what your core values are. And if they do – just objectively consider the other person’s point of view. If there’s anything constructive there – take it. If not, just brush it off (mentally) and actually be happy that you have lived to your standards one more time.

I find it’s very helpful to resist judging in return. It is a lot better to let the other person have their opinion if you can see that they aren’t willing to be objective.
.-= Anita´s last blog ..Great Inspirational Quotes – What ‘Clicks’ With You? =-.

Reply

Sibyl June 10, 2010 at 9:26 pm

Anita: Thanks so much for the comment. I really appreciate it and couldn’t agree more that it is all about being able to brush it off and be happy that you are living according to your own truth. I think the point you made about resisting judging was an important one. We really also do need to make certain we aren’t falling into the trap of passing judgment. Thanks again for the comment. I really appreciate it.

Reply

John Soares June 10, 2010 at 1:46 pm

Sibyl, I really appreciate that you say we should listen to the criticism and see what truth there may be in it, but then to follow our inner guidance regarding who we really are.

Frequently unfair criticism comes from a person who is unhappy about some aspect of his or her own life, and they project it on you.

Thanks for making me think!
.-= John Soares´s last blog ..The Importance of Free Time Alone =-.

Reply

Sibyl June 10, 2010 at 9:28 pm

John: Thanks for the comment. I really appreciate it. I agree with you that unfair criticism often times comes from a person that is unhappy with some aspect of their own life and they end up projecting their unhappiness on to you. When this does happen, we really do just have to make certain that we aren’t getting caught up in their negativity and whatever else it is they have going on. Thanks again for the comment. It was a really good one and I am glad the post made you think.

Reply

Dia June 10, 2010 at 6:33 pm

Hi Sibyl,

Thanks for this article. I like how you mentioned that some people feel it is their responsibility to tell us if we made a mistake or how to live our lives. How many times we come across someone that questions how we live our lives? Some try to advise us by saying things like “Don’t waste your money on traveling” or “You don’t know how life is” among other statements. For me personally, the way I deal with such situations is by thinking to myself that “each one of us is different and that if we all think alike, life would be boring, so that is good that they disagree with me because each person has his own thoughts and lifestyle.” I always keep those thoughts in my head and keep reminding myself that those who criticize me, they do because they have different lifestyles, thinking etc….

Thanks for sharing Sibyl :)
.-= Dia´s last blog ..Program your mind for success =-.

Reply

Sibyl June 10, 2010 at 9:32 pm

Dia: Thank you so much for the comment. I really appreciate you always dropping by and living so many great comments on my posts. I think that we all have firsthand knowledge of unfair criticism and it is important to have a solid approach for responding and dealing with it. Thanks for sharing what has worked for you. And, thanks again for the comment and stopping by the alternaview.

Reply

Rocky | R O C K O N O V A . COM June 11, 2010 at 8:34 am

great post Sibyl ! Taking responsibility for our response to criticism is the best way to remind ourselves of the power we have . And staying calm is definitely one of the most effective ways to handle any situation.
.-= Rocky | R O C K O N O V A . COM´s last blog ..The Beauty Of Being A White Belt =-.

Reply

Sibyl June 11, 2010 at 9:29 am

Rocky: Thanks for the comment. It is always great to hear from you. I couldn’t agree more that staying calm and reminding ourselves of the power we really have is the best way to respond to criticism. It all is about finding an approach that works for you and then consistently choosing to respond in the best manner possible. Thanks again for the comment. Have a great weekend.

Reply

S. Ali Myers - Soulful Body & Mind June 11, 2010 at 8:40 am

Sibyl,

I’m glad I stumbled upon your blog!

#1 – Stay calm. This is something I practice all day, every day. Not just with handling criticism, but life in general. When we are calm, we can assess everything and output a clear, productive decision or view.

As far as being immune to criticism, let’s look at it this way. I’m a very confident, borderline “cocky” person. Sometimes, criticism helps ground me. I know I have had “dreamy” ideas that my significant other has brought me back down to earth on. So, it was in my best interest to ‘take in” the criticism as oppose to being immune to it.

Keep up the great work here!

- Ali
.-= S. Ali Myers – Soulful Body & Mind´s last blog ..Are There Really Ghosts? =-.

Reply

Sibyl June 11, 2010 at 9:35 am

Ali: I am glad that you stumbled across my blog as well. Welcome to the alternaview. It is great to have you here. I think what you said is so important about staying calm in general. This has been a process for me, but it is so important and literally changes the way you experience and appreciate everything. I also liked what you said about accepting some of the good advice that is coming your way. All advice definitely doesn’t fall into the unfair criticism bucket and that is why we have to make sure that we are rationally responding and tuning in so that we don’t miss out on constructive advice that can help us. Thank you again for the comment. I really appreciate it.

Reply

fatima da June 11, 2010 at 12:06 pm

Great points Sibyl , fortunately or unfortunately we are all open to criticism even the best man on the planet if at all there is any will fall a victim. As long as we exist and engage with others we cannot escape it but then you have provided outstanding points to cope … My best way forward is usually to stay calm. Thanks for posting :)
.-= fatima da´s last blog ..Envy and Jealously The Stupid Inferiors =-.

Reply

Sibyl June 11, 2010 at 6:28 pm

Fatima: Thanks for the comment. Much appreciated. I agree that no matter who we are and what we are doing, we will most likely find ourselves subject to criticism. I think it is all about finding that approach that works for you and allows you to manage through criticism so that it doesn’t negatively impact your peace of mind or work against you and hold you back. Your advice of staying calm is great. Everything just always goes so much better when we can maintain that calm piece of mind. Thanks so much again for the comment.

Reply

Roman Soluk June 12, 2010 at 5:43 am

Criticism can be really disastrous for our goals. Last year I also wrote about this as it was really a problem for me some time ago. Now it’s not, as I know that I was right not them.

We should simply do what we like, what we believe in and we’ll succeed. Thanks for this truly helpful post, Sibyl!
.-= Roman Soluk´s last blog ..How to avoid food poisoning =-.

Reply

Sibyl June 13, 2010 at 9:07 am

Roman: Thanks for the comment and sharing your personal insight. Criticism really can be disastrous for our goals and where we are trying to go. However, if we do figure out a way to put it into perspective and not allow it to prevent or interfere with where we are going, then there is no amount of criticism that can stand in our way. I am glad that you had that realization as well. Thanks again for the comment. I really appreciate it.

Reply

Ayo June 12, 2010 at 5:51 am

hello sibyl,
how are you?
thanks for sharing this and i loved the points raised.
staying calm gives you control of your mind/thoughts and it prevents you from starting a shouting match if the criticism seemed unfair. at the same time it prevents you from making irrational decisionsuch as stopping a project & feeling like failure when faced with constructive criticism on how you handled a project. Your calmness could also reinforce being assertive.
i think finding ways to have good thoughts about the person is really important despite our egos getting in the way because it’s bruised laugh!!!
i could go on and on but…..
take care of yourself and have a lovely weekend.
.-= Ayo´s last blog ..The Fifth Edition Of The Life Skills Magazine Is Out Now!! =-.

Reply

Sibyl June 13, 2010 at 9:12 am

Ayo: Always so good to hear from you. I really thought what you said was really important about not allowing criticism to interfere with your ability to be calm because that is when you give unfair criticism way too much control. I am glad that you agreed with the point about having good thoughts about the person. You are so right that the ego can make it challenging to actually be able to do that, but I do think if you can genuinely focus about some of the good things the person has to offer, it just allows you to see them in a much better light. Thanks again for the comment Ayo.

Reply

Jarrod - inspirational words June 12, 2010 at 12:01 pm

Hi Sibyl,

I love your tips here. It’s not always easy to just dismiss negative criticism that we receive from others. But I love how you mentioned to find things you like about the person. Sometimes it’s helpful just to understand the fact that people will attempt to tear others down just because it makes them feel better. When looking at it from this perspective it almost makes you feel sorry for that person. That they have to resort to such a low level to make themselves feel better. Makes you thankful to have to self-confidence that you don’t have to resort to such a low level. Some people binge on food to numb the pain, others have addictions, and some people tear down other people to numb the pain. Sometimes it helps just to understand this concept, and puts you in a mind-frame of sympathy.
.-= Jarrod – inspirational words´s last blog ..Are You Spreading The Good News? =-.

Reply

Sibyl June 13, 2010 at 9:17 am

Jarrod: Thanks so much for the insightful comment. I do agree that sometimes being able to see people in a different light and understand that their criticism about you may have more to do with their own challenges can help you have sympathy. I think it is all about finding whatever it is about the person that allows you to see them in a better way instead of simply as someone who has offended you. Thanks again for the comment and sharing your insights. I really appreciate it.

Reply

Amit Sodha - The Power Of Choice June 14, 2010 at 7:51 am

Hi Sibyl,

Criticism is our biggest gift. The way I’ve look at is that those who do come to criticise me do so and are serving a purpose in my life. They are my greatest allies in my pursuit of growth. If you look at the great sages like Jesus, or Buddha or the Dalai Lama or Gandhi, did they not have a flock of massive critics? I will to stake my life on the fact that they welcomed all of it because it was their gift to love them no matter what.

I even remember a comedian recently saying that if you don’t have haters you aren’t there yet.

I don’t think it’s necessary to think of 5 good things about the person who’s criticised you, I believe there’s only one thought you need, “how did they serve you?” How was their actions of service to you?

You or some may view this as a criticism and if it does challenge you wonderful, I’ve served my purpose in not just saying things to please people but I may have served yours in aiding you to grow.

All the best,
.-= Amit Sodha – The Power Of Choice´s last blog ..Video – How To Solve Any Puzzle In Life =-.

Reply

Sibyl June 14, 2010 at 9:36 pm

Amit: Welcome to the alternaview. Thank you so much for the thought provoking comment. I think that you have a very good understanding of criticism and the purpose it serves in your life. It is very impressive to hear exactly how you process criticism and how you view it as a great gift. I do agree with you that challenges and criticism can serve as your greatest opportunity to growth if you view it from the right perspective. Your perspective is refreshing to hear and I am so glad that you stopped by to share it on the alternaview. Thank you so much again for the comment. It is great to have you commenting here and to be able to have this discussion with you.

Reply

Mark of Success June 14, 2010 at 10:47 am

Hi Sibyl,

First of all, I must say you have a beautiful site!
This is my first comment on your blog, and I’m sure I’ll be back for more.

Like you rightly said, unfair criticism can really invade our peace of mind. And I whole heartedly believe that any person providing unfair and unjustified criticism is doing so for that very same reason!

I’m certainly not immune to unfair criticism. So one good technique that I use personally, is as follows:

Firstly, I tell myself that if someone wanted to provide constructive criticism, he/she would have done it in a much better way, in a way that would be helpful and motivating rather than depressing. And if that was not the case, then the person would have only wanted to hurt me.

Secondly, I rise above the situation and look down upon the person (mentally), and feel pity for his low act. Then I forgive the person for his/her futile attempt to discourage me, and “release” him/her into open space.

What do you have to say about this technique?

Wishing you Success
Mark @ Secrets of Success
.-= Mark of Success´s last blog ..If you think you know what an ideal work life balance is, read this! =-.

Reply

Sibyl June 15, 2010 at 9:27 pm

Mark: Thank you for the comment and the kind words. Welcome to the alternaview. It is so great to have you here. I think your technique is a really good approach because it gets you to the point where you are able to forgive the person and move on. You know that you have a great approach if other people’s unfair criticism doesn’t impact your peace of mind for too long. It sounds like your technique definitely delivers on that. Thank you so much for the insightful comment and stopping by the alternaview. I really do appreciate it.

Reply

rob white June 14, 2010 at 12:09 pm

Hi Sibyl,
Great discussion here. When we take criticism personally it can get a grip on our mood and send us in a downward spiral. Criticism is a very valuable thing when we view it properly. With all criticism be it fair or unfair is a great asset when we learn not to take things personally. We are empowered to correct what needs correcting or forgive those who just may be having a bad day.
.-= rob white´s last blog ..What’s Right with You? =-.

Reply

Sibyl June 14, 2010 at 9:39 pm

Rob: Always good to hear from you. I agree that this discussion is a really interesting one. I actually left the post up a little longer than I had originally intended because I was really enjoying listening to the comments and the discussion. Thanks for contributing to the conversation. I do agree with both you and Amit that criticism can really prove to be a valuable thing if you view it properly because there is always an opportunity to respond in the best way and grow. Thank you again for adding a fresh perspective and your own insight to the conversation. I really appreciate it.

Reply

Leisa Watkins @ Wealth, Wisdom And Success June 18, 2010 at 1:38 pm

Hi Sibyl.

Enjoyed this article! Of course, that isn’t rare on your blog.

I really liked the insight you had when you said, “We should ask ourselves if what we have done or how we have behaved is consistent with our own truth and who we know we should be.”

If we don’t weigh the criticism against our own truth and what our mission is in life than we are much more likely to live the life someone else designed for us – rather than living the life we were meant to live.

~ Leisa
.-= Leisa Watkins @ Wealth, Wisdom And Success´s last blog ..Are Your Dreams Guiding You To The Wrong Shore Line? =-.

Reply

Sibyl June 19, 2010 at 7:46 am

Leisa: Thank you for the comment and the kind words. I am so glad that you enjoy the posts on the alternaview. It really means a lot to hear that, so thank you. As you mentioned, I think it really is all about ensuring that we are following our own truth. There are always so many opinions out there, but what matters the most is that we are being true to ourselves and staying consistent with our own core beliefs. Thank you again for the comment.

Reply

Farnoosh June 30, 2010 at 11:10 am

Oh I can so use this advice for fair or unfair criticism. Mostly it is the former and delivered in such sweet notes too that you would think me the most impatient being for jumping all over him, but my husband is too good to point out some of my flaws and I must be kinder to him in return. Thanks for the reminder, Sibyl!

Reply

Sibyl July 2, 2010 at 5:23 am

Farnoosh: Thanks for the comment. I think we can all become better at opening our minds to fair criticism and it always is better when husbands deliver it ever so gently :) Thanks again for the comment. I really enjoy hearing your thoughts here on the alternaview. Have a great weekend.

Reply

Carl July 21, 2010 at 9:10 pm

Live in such a way as to never be ashamed of what someone might say about you — even if what they say is not true. — Richard Bach, “Illusions”

Mulling over this sentence for three decades has brought me much peace.

Reply

Sibyl July 21, 2010 at 10:22 pm

Carl: Welcome to the alternaview and thank you for the comment. I think that is great advice to make certain that you are always staying true to yourself and your core beliefs when it comes to your thoughts and actions. If we can just make certain we area always interacting in a way we would be proud of, it really helps us to live in a great way and of course friction free. Thanks so much for the comment again. Much appreciated.

Reply

bendedspoon September 20, 2010 at 6:24 pm

hello!
glad to find this site
your alternaview.
i just have gained something
‘Find a way to Have Good Thoughts About the Person’.
i usually ignore unfair criticisms
but deep inside i develop a dislike to the person.
it’s not a good feeling
unfair to myself.
it’s not hard to find good things in others
until they unfairly criticize you
but now it can be done
and thanks to you! :)

Reply

Sibyl September 23, 2010 at 6:07 pm

Welcome to the alternaview and thanks for the comment. I am glad that you found this site too and that you enjoyed this alternaview. It can be challenging to find good things about people who criticize us and treat us unfairly, but if we can just take a step back and see them in the best light, we really set ourselves up to have the best relationships and interactions with other people. Thanks again for the comment and stopping by the alternaview. I really appreciate it.

Reply

{ 1 trackback }

Previous post:

Next post:

30642